Find Missing Tammy Mahoney! (Part Two)

Find Missing Tammy Mahoney!

Find missing Tammy Mahoney!
It has been almost four decades
Since her family and friends last saw her.
It has been almost four decades
Since her family and friends last heard from her.
Her loved ones are calling for justice
And they need answers.
What happened to this missing teen girl?

Find Missing Tammy Mahoney!

Find Missing Tammy Mahoney!

Missing Person: Tammy Mahoney
Missing Since
Missing From
Oneida, New York
Endangered Missing
Date of Birth
08/29/1961 (57 years old current age)
Age when last seen
19 years old
Height and Weight
5’3, 130 pounds
Clothing/Jewelry Description
A dark-colored v-neck sweater or sweatshirt with white embroidery at the neck and wrists; blue jeans or bib overalls with a 29-inch waist; a dark-colored or denim jacket; a size 36D bra; and possibly size 6 clogs, sandals or white low-top sneakers; a size 5 – 6 silver ring with a green stone; a small cross necklace with turquoise stones; and a very thin dime-sized metal medallion depicting a guardian angel and a bridge with two children crossing.
Distinguishing Characteristics
Caucasian female. Brown hair, green eyes. Mahoney’s ears are pierced. She has freckles. Her nails are short and she may bite them. Mahoney fractured her lower leg as a child.

This is the Part Two of the story of Tammy Mahoney. It is continued from Part One. You can read it here.

Find Missing Tammy Mahoney!

Investigators believe that Tammy Mahoney was gang-raped and murdered. They believed this happened to her at a party. It probably occurred inside a trailer on the Oneida Indian Nation Territory. And this incident would have occurred shortly after she was last seen. Authorities received a tip that Mahoney’s body was inside a building that burned down on Lenox Avenue on May 11.

An extensive search of the area produced no clues as to her whereabouts. Mahoney’s disappearance was reclassified as a probable homicide sometime afterwards.

Investigators announced that they identified several male suspects in Mahoney’s presumed murder. They did so in the spring of 2002. The men’s names have not been publicly released. But not all of the suspects are members of the Oneida Indian Nation.

Authorities said that dozens of witnesses were inside the trailer at the time of her homicide. And the murder suspects still live in the local area. The federal government will prosecute Mahoney’s case, since she was allegedly killed on Indian Nation property. Investigators cannot file charges against anyone until her body is recovered.

A man’s wallet was turned into authorities by an unidentified individual. This occurred several days after Mahoney disappeared. The wallet was located on the Territory and investigators said it is connected to her case. The identity of its owner has not been divulged, but officials requested that the person who recovered the item contact detectives in order to obtain additional evidence.

Someone scrawled a message. And the names of two alleged suspects on a reward flyer posted in A Guy, A Gal and a Laundromat. This incident occurred in Vernon, New York in March 2002. Investigators made a public plea for photos of the Indian Nation Territory. And any junked vehicles from May 1981 around the same time.

Authorities announced that Mahoney’s body may have been placed inside one of the cars. It would have ended up there immediately after her murder. Officials searched a gravel-covered lot near the Shako:wi Cultural Center on the Territory in late June 2002. A pond was located in the area at the time of Mahoney’s disappearance, but was filled in sometime afterwards.

No evidence was uncovered during the search. Investigators said that they did not believe her remains were still inside the car, but materials related to her case may be inside the vehicle.

Tammy Mahoney was born in the Long Island, New York area. Her case remains unsolved.

Find Missing Tammy Mahoney!

Tammy Mahoney has been missing for 38 years. As of this writing, she has spent twice as many years missing as she has seen alive. Her family need answers, justice, and as much peace as possible. Sadly, authorities are searching for Mahoney’s remains. Common sense tells us that she would not spend all this time hiding herself under the radar. Do you have any information concerning the whereabouts of Tammy Mahoney? Do you have any information concerning the person (s) who may be involved in her disappearance?

Find Missing Tammy Mahoney!
Contact Information

If you have any information, please contact the Oneida Police Department (New York) 1-315-363-9111. You may contact the Madison County Sheriff’s Department (New York): 1-315-366-2289. You can contact the FBI tip line: 1-800-CALL-FBI (1-800-225-5324). You can leave an online tip at: this webpage. OR You can contact your local FBI office. You can also contact FBI International Offices. You may call 9-1-1 or your local police.

NamUs Case Number: MP7601
Agency Case Number: 81-1985
NCIC Number: M-118604726

JUSTICE FOR TAMMY MAHONEY is a Facebook page set up for her. Use Facebook? Feel free to “like” this page.
This is a video appeal for Tammy Mahoney. Click here to watch.
This is a THE PHILOSOPY OF CRIME profile of Tammy Mahoney. Click here to learn more.
This is a 2019 article about Tammy Mahoney. Click here to learn more.
This is a 2019 article about Tammy Mahoney. Click here to learn more.
This is a CRIMEWATCHERS.NET page for Tammy Mahoney. It has many photos of searches for the missing older teen girl. Click here to learn more.
This is a COLD CASE SPOTLIGHT page for Tammy Mahoney. Click here to learn more.
Tammy Mahoney has a Doe Network profile. Click here to learn more.
Tammy Mahoney has a NamUs profile. Click here to view it.
This is a timeline of Tammy Mahoney’s disappearance and the investigation into it. Click here to learn more.
Tammy Mahoney has an FBI poster. The above image is courtesy of this profile. Click here to learn more.
The above information is found on Tammy Mahoney’s Charley Project page. I have adapted and remixed it. It is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial 4.0 International Licence.

I'm a Christian, meaning that I have a relationship with God, through trust in His Son Jesus. Through this website, which is currently the only website I have, It is a full-time job to give myself to this website, which includes updating cases. I seek to broadcast missing people, unidentified people, and crime victims. These include those of all ages, races, religions, and walks of life. If you see something on here that needs an update, please contact me. Thank you.

Leave a Reply Text

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.